Verdict change report

CWST is no longer halal under FTSE

Casella Waste Systems, Inc. (CWST) moved from halal to not halal under FTSE Shariah.

Verdict under FTSE
not halal
Screens FTSE applies
5
Balance-sheet denominator
total assets
CWST market cap, averaged
$5.97bn
17 November 2026Recorded 17 Nov 2026, 12:09US

By Akinda Research. The change is from our own screening run for this date; the rules quoted below are each standard's own published methodology as we implement it. No cause is inferred and no commentary is added.

What changed

FTSE Shariah

FTSE Russell (Yasaar) · screened by Yasaar · Quarterly — March, June, September, December

Before

halal

After this run

not halal

What FTSE measures

  • Excluded activitiesThe base list, plus defense, hotels, cinema, music, and cannabis in any form.
  • Non-compliant income(interest + non-compliant activities income) ÷ revenue only — ≤ 5%
  • Debtdebt ÷ total assets — < 33.333%
  • Cash / liquidity(cash + interest-bearing items) ÷ total assets — < 33.333%
  • Receivables(accounts receivable + cash) ÷ total assets — < 50%

Ratios divide by a total assets. FTSE Russell (Yasaar) tolerates ±5% relative over 2 quarters before dropping a constituent, so a company can read non-compliant here and still sit in an index that has not removed it.

  • The only methodology whose income denominator is revenue alone — interest income is not added back.

MSCI Islamic

Morgan Stanley Capital International · screened by MSCI Solutions / Ideal Ratings (business-involvement data) · Quarterly index review — February, May, August, November

Before

halal

After this run

not halal

What MSCI measures

  • Excluded activitiesThe base list, plus defense, hotels, music (including musical instruments), cinema, and online dating.
  • Non-compliant income(prohibited revenue + interest) ÷ (revenue + interest) — ≤ 5%
  • Debttotal debt ÷ total assets — ≤ 33.33%
  • Cash / liquidity(cash + interest-bearing securities) ÷ total assets — ≤ 33.33%
  • Receivables(accounts receivable + cash) ÷ total assets — ≤ 70%

Ratios divide by a total assets. Morgan Stanley Capital International tolerates Entry and exit buffers before dropping a constituent, so a company can read non-compliant here and still sit in an index that has not removed it.

  • The thresholds shown are the existing-constituent ones. MSCI's tighter entry thresholds apply only when a stock joins an MSCI index.
  • MSCI's hotel exclusion has a December-2025 carve-out — hotels in predominantly Islamic countries that offer Sharia-compliant activities are not treated as prohibited exposure.

A verdict belongs to a standard, not to a company. Casella Waste Systems, Inc. is not halal under FTSE Shariah Global Equity Index Series as of this run; the other four standards reach their own answer on the same filings, and they frequently disagree. The rest of this report is what FTSE tests, what can move it, and how the other four differ on the same question.

How FTSE screens a company

FTSE Shariah Global Equity Index Series is maintained by FTSE Russell (Yasaar), with screening performed by Yasaar. Balance-sheet based throughout, and the strictest on what counts as revenue. Review cadence: Quarterly — March, June, September, December. The balance-sheet ratios divide by a total assets.

ScreenWhat FTSE applies
Excluded activitiesThe base list, plus defense, hotels, cinema, music, and cannabis in any form.
Non-compliant income(interest + non-compliant activities income) ÷ revenue only — ≤ 5%the only methodology whose denominator is revenue alone — interest income is not added back to it.
Debtdebt ÷ total assets — < 33.333%
Cash / liquidity(cash + interest-bearing items) ÷ total assets — < 33.333%
Receivables(accounts receivable + cash) ÷ total assets — < 50%

Primary source: FTSE Yasaar Global Equity Shariah Index Series — Ground Rules

What moves a verdict under this standard

Four things change a Shariah verdict, and only two of them are decisions the company made.

  1. The balance sheet moved

    New borrowing, a cash build-up or a change in receivables moves the ratio directly. Under FTSE the test is debt ÷ total assets — < 33.333%.

  2. The share price did not do it

    FTSE divides by total assets rather than by market capitalisation, so a falling share price does not move this ratio at all. That is the foremost reason the five standards disagree about the same company on the same day.

  3. The business was re-classified

    Akinda applies each methodology's published financial ratios. The business-activity classification is Akinda's own, built from company filings. It is not the index provider's own screening data. Akinda is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or licensed by AAOIFI, S&P Dow Jones Indices, FTSE Russell, MSCI or Yasaar. A change in what a company earns from — or in how that revenue is reported — can cross the activity screen with no ratio moving at all.

  4. The standard moved its own limit

    A rulebook can revise its thresholds, and every company sitting between the old line and the new one changes verdict without acting. When the Dow Jones Islamic Market standard lowered its debt limit from 33% to 30% and added a 30% cash screen on 19 September 2026, the next run recorded 354 companies changing verdict under that standard alone. Where a report can tell that this is what happened, it says so in place of blaming the company.

The same test, under all five standards

Debt is applied by every recognised standard, and no two apply it the same way. This is why a single blended verdict hides more than it tells — and why Casella Waste Systems, Inc. can read one way under FTSE and another way elsewhere.

StandardIts ruleDivides by
AAOIFI(short-term + long-term debt) ÷ 12-quarter average market cap — fails at ≥ 30%12-quarter average market cap
DJIMinterest-bearing debt ÷ 24-month average market cap — < 33% through 2026-09-18, < 30% from 2026-09-1924-month average market cap
FTSEthis reportdebt ÷ total assets — < 33.333%total assets
MSCItotal debt ÷ total assets — ≤ 33.33%total assets
S&Pdebt ÷ 36-month average market value of equity — < 33%36-month average market value of equity

Each standard's own rule, quoted as we implement it. The differences in the fourth significant figure are not typos: a company at exactly 33.33% passes one standard and fails another.

Check CWST yourself

This report is one measurement on one date. The current verdict, under all five standards with the ratio behind each, is one call:

GET /api/v1/full-report/CWST

FTSE's own fields on that response are halal_status_ftse, non_compliant_revenue_perc_ftse, debt_ratio_perc_ftse, liquidity_ratio_perc_ftse, receivables_ratio_perc_ftse, and the verdict itself is halal_status_ftse.

Method and limits

  • A changed verdict is not always a changed company. Where a standard moved its own limit, this report says so rather than attributing it to the company.
  • Not every change is about a ratio. Roughly one in ten is a business-activity or instrument screen, where no number moved. Those carry no figures, deliberately.
  • Market capitalisation here is an average, not a quote. It runs over 12 to 36 months depending on the standard, so it will not match a price site. It is the figure the debt screens themselves divide by.
  • A verdict is per standard and per date. Nothing here states a company's compliance in general, because no such single answer exists.

This is screening data presented for information. It is not investment advice and it is not a religious ruling. AAOIFI, Dow Jones, FTSE, MSCI and S&P publish their own standards and we are not affiliated with any of them; what is reported here is what each published methodology produces when applied to a company's filings.

Common questions

Why did this company change verdict without any news?

Three of the five standards divide debt by an average market capitalisation rather than by total assets, so the ratio moves when the share price does. A company whose price falls far enough becomes non-compliant without issuing a dollar of new debt. The averages run over 12 to 36 months, so a single day's move never does it alone.

Can a standard change its own rules?

Yes, and it happens. On 19 September 2026 the Dow Jones Islamic Market standard lowered its debt limit from 33% to 30% and added a cash screen it had never had. The next screening run recorded 354 companies changing verdict under that standard alone — none of which had changed. Where a report can tell that this is what happened, it says so rather than blaming the company.

Why do the standards disagree about the same company?

They use different limits, different comparators and different denominators. MSCI tests debt above 33.33% while FTSE tests at 33.333% or above, so a company at exactly 33.33% passes one and fails the other. FTSE and MSCI divide by total assets; AAOIFI and S&P divide by a 12-quarter average market cap; Dow Jones uses a 24-month one. That is why every figure on this page names the standard it belongs to.

Does a non-compliant verdict mean the shares must be sold?

That is a decision for the holder and their own scholar, and this page does not make it. What the data supports is narrower: under this standard, on this date, the company did not pass. Most frameworks that permit continued holding require purification of the non-compliant share of income, which is a separate calculation from the screen itself.

Is this a religious ruling?

No. We report what each published methodology produces when applied to a company's filings, and we name which methodology produced it. The standards are the work of their own scholars and boards, and we are not affiliated with AAOIFI, Dow Jones, FTSE, MSCI or S&P.

More verdict change reports

Keep reading

Every verdict change, as it happens

This report is one company on one date. The full feed — every stock and fund, every standard, with the ratio behind each change — is an API endpoint.

CWST is no longer halal under FTSE — 17 November 2026